Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of the cephalometric measurements between manual and AI analyses

From: Evaluating the accuracy of automated cephalometric analysis based on artificial intelligence

Bias

Mean (mm)

SD

(mm)

95% limits of agreement (mm)

P valuea

Proportion within

95% limits of agreement (%)

Lower

Upper

Skeletal measurements (9)

SNA (°)

2.50

2.94

-3.25

8.26

0.00

95.29

SNB (°)

2.21

2.76

-3.21

7.62

0.00

95.29

ANB (°)

0.30

0.94

-1.55

2.14

0.01

95.29

SND (°)

1.42

2.69

-3.86

6.69

0.00

94.12

NP-FH (°)

-1.50

1.60

-4.63

1.63

0.00

91.76

MP-FH (°)

2.53

1.93

-1.26

6.32

0.00

96.47

MP-SN (°)

-0.94

3.19

-7.19

5.31

0.01

96.47

Y axis (°)

1.22

1.98

-2.66

5.11

0.00

95.29

Pg-NB (mm)

-0.41

0.84

-2.06

1.23

0.00

95.29

Dental measurements (12)

U1-NA (mm)

-0.49

1.34

-3.12

2.13

0.00

95.29

U1-NA (°)

-0.36

3.03

-6.29

5.58

0.28

95.29

L1-NB (mm)

-0.56

0.93

-2.37

1.26

0.00

95.29

L1-NB (°)

2.78

3.10

-3.29

8.85

0.00

94.12

U1-L1 (°)

-2.72

4.67

-11.87

6.44

0.00

94.12

U1-SN (°)

2.14

4.06

-5.81

10.09

0.00

98.82

L1-MP (°)

1.52

3.41

-5.17

8.21

0.00

92.94

L1-FH (°)

-4.05

3.44

-10.80

2.70

0.00

95.29

U1-AP (mm)

-0.15

0.84

-1.79

1.48

0.10

96.47

U1-AP (°)

0.57

2.98

-5.28

6.42

0.08

94.12

L1-AP (mm)

-0.51

0.97

-2.40

1.39

0.00

96.47

L1-AP (°)

2.15

3.33

-4.38

8.67

0.00

96.47

Soft tissue measurements (2)

LL-EP (mm)

-0.41

0.57

-1.52

0.70

0.00

91.76

UL-EP (mm)

-0.15

0.80

-1.72

1.42

0.09

95.29

  1. SD Standard deviation
  2. aResults of a paired t test between manual and AI detection. All data were found to be normally distributed according to the Shapiro‒Wilk test