Skip to main content

Table 2 The bias between manual and automatic detection and the SDR of automatic detection

From: Evaluating the accuracy of automated cephalometric analysis based on artificial intelligence

Landmarks

MRE (mm)

SD (mm)

95% CI (mm)

SDR (%)

Lower

Upper

< 1 mm

< 2 mm

< 2.5 mm

< 3 mm

< 4 mm

Skeletal landmarks (11)

S

2.61

1.88

-1.07

6.29

7.06

57.65

63.53

71.76

81.18

N

2.63

2.31

-1.90

7.16

28.24

55.29

62.35

63.53

77.65

P

2.24

1.14

0.01

4.47

11.76

51.76

62.35

78.82

95.29

Or

1.97

1.07

-0.13

4.07

16.47

58.82

72.94

87.06

96.47

A

1.39

0.87

-0.32

3.10

35.29

77.65

85.88

95.29

98.82

B

1.96

1.19

-0.37

4.29

20.00

61.18

71.76

80.00

94.12

Go

3.08

1.67

-0.19

6.35

3.53

25.88

48.24

58.82

75.29

Pg

1.31

0.57

0.19

2.43

32.94

87.06

96.47

98.82

100.00

Gn

1.77

0.53

0.73

2.81

4.71

65.88

89.41

97.65

100.00

Me

2.41

0.65

1.14

3.68

3.53

20.00

54.12

85.88

98.82

D

2.27

0.86

0.58

3.96

5.88

41.18

64.71

83.53

96.47

Average

2.15

1.37

-0.54

4.84

15.40

54.76

70.16

81.92

92.19

Dental landmarks (4)

U1 tip

1.06

0.49

0.10

2.02

45.88

97.65

98.82

98.82

98.82

U1 root

4.14

1.33

1.53

6.75

1.18

4.71

9.41

22.35

43.53

L1 tip

1.41

0.86

-0.28

3.10

31.76

87.06

94.12

96.47

97.65

L1 root

2.85

0.93

1.03

4.67

0.00

17.65

35.29

62.35

90.59

Average

2.37

1.55

-0.67

5.41

19.71

51.77

59.41

70.00

82.65

Soft tissue landmarks (4)

Prn

1.01

0.48

0.07

1.95

51.76

97.65

98.82

98.82

100.00

UL

1.40

0.78

-0.13

2.93

34.12

83.53

91.76

95.29

98.82

LL

1.80

0.74

0.35

3.25

9.41

64.71

85.88

94.12

98.82

Pg′

1.97

0.98

0.05

3.89

14.12

57.65

76.47

89.41

94.12

Average

1.54

0.85

-0.13

3.21

27.35

75.89

88.23

94.41

97.94

Total average

2.07

1.35

-0.58

4.72

18.82

58.58

71.70

82.04

91.39

  1. SD Standard deviation; CI Confidence interval