Table 2 Table displaying the percentage of applicable Drummond and CHEERS criteria met by each paper, with categorisation to indicate overall quality
From: A systematic review of the quality and scope of economic evaluations in child oral health research
First author | % applicable Drummond criteria met | Overall methodological quality | % applicable CHEERS criteria met | Overall reporting quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Alkhadra, T. [22] | 38 | Moderate | 65 | Moderate |
Atkins, C. [23] | 46 | Moderate | 96 | High |
Bergström, E. [24] | 23 | Low | 70 | Moderate |
Bertrand, É. [25] | 54 | High | 91 | High |
Bhuridej, P. [26] | 92 | High | 86 | High |
Chi, D. [27] | 69 | High | 96 | High |
Davies, G. [28] | 54 | High | 90 | High |
Frazão, P. [29] | 54 | High | 48 | Low |
Goldman, A. [30] | 85 | High | 90 | High |
Goldman, A. [31] | 100 | High | 95 | High |
Griffin, S. [32] | 77 | High | 87 | High |
Hichens, L. [33] | 36 | Moderate | 84 | High |
Hietasalo, P. [34] | 69 | High | 50 | Low |
Hirsch, G. [35] | 0 | Low | 39 | Low |
Holland, T. [36] | 62 | High | 35 | Low |
Jokela, J. [37] | 8 | Low | 60 | Low |
Kaakko, T. [38] | 15 | Low | 52 | Low |
Koh, R. [39] | 77 | High | 96 | High |
Kowash, M. [40] | 15 | Low | 85 | High |
Leskinen, K. [41] | 8 | Low | 76 | Moderate |
Marino, R. [42] | 77 | High | 87 | High |
Mariño, R. [43] | 54 | High | 67 | Moderate |
Mariño, R. [44] | 54 | High | 76 | Moderate |
Morgan, M. [45] | 38 | Moderate | 81 | Moderate |
Neidell, M. [46] | 38 | Moderate | 77 | Moderate |
Ney, J. P. [47] | 38 | Moderate | 87 | High |
Oscarson, N. [48] | 85 | High | 90 | High |
Ouyang, W. [49] | 69 | High | 87 | High |
Petrén, S. [50] | 38 | Moderate | 62 | Low |
Pukallus, M. [51] | 54 | High | 100 | High |
Quiñonez, R. [52] | 54 | High | 82 | Moderate |
Quinonez, R. [53] | 62 | High | 95 | High |
Ramos-Gomez, F. [54] | 8 | Low | 55 | Low |
Sakuma, S. [55] | 62 | High | 62 | Low |
Samnaliev, M. [56] | 46 | Moderate | 100 | High |
Sköld, U. [57] | 62 | High | 91 | High |
Stearns, S. [58] | 46 | Moderate | 100 | High |
Tagliaferro, E. [59] | 77 | High | 43 | Low |
Tickle, M. [60] | 38 | Moderate | 95 | High |
Tonmukayakul, U. [61] | 46 | Moderate | 95 | High |
Vermaire, J. [62] | 100 | High | 90 | High |
Weintraub, J. [63] | 0 | Low | 78 | Moderate |
Wiedel, A. [64] | 23 | Low | 71 | Moderate |
Wu, Y. [65] | 8 | Low | 33 | Low |
Yee, R. [66] | 23 | Low | 71 | Moderate |
Zabos, G. [67] | 31 | Low | 57 | Low |
Categorisation | Drummond criteria met | CHEERS criteria met | ||
High | > 50% | > 83% | ||
Moderate | 32–50% | 63–83% | ||
Low | < 32% | < 63% | ||