Skip to main content

Table 1 List of the analyzed studies dealing with the non-surgical approach [15] (updated 2015)

From: Influence of different post-interventional maintenance concepts on periodontal outcomes: an evaluation of three systematic reviews

Postoperative controls

Antiseptics Application

A: 1 + 2 weeks B: 3 + 4 weeks C: 5+ weeks

 

Maintenance protocol in the first 2 months

1: ≤ 2x 2: ≥ 3x

Study

Antiseptic

Galenic formulation

Application frequency

Duration

Category

Supragingival cleaning

Intervals (weeks)

Category

Pihlstrom & Ortiz 1981

n.r.

    

yes

Recall frequency varied, 3–4x/yr

1

Lindhe & Westfeldt 1982

CHX

0.2 %

2x/d

2 weeks

A

yes

6 month every 2nd week, then 3 month rec for 18 month

2

Pihlstrom & McHugh 1983

n.r.

    

yes

Recall 3–4x/yr

1

Lindhe & Westfeldt 1984

     

yes

6 month every 2nd week, then 3 month rec for 18 month

2

Pihlstrom & Oliphant 1984

n.r.

    

yes

Recall frequency varied, 3–4x/yr

1

Isidor & Karring 1984

CHX

0.2 %

2x/d

2 weeks

A

yes

2 year 1, professional prophylaxis 3-monthly year 2, 6-monthly years 3, 4 & 5 – subgingival debridement

2

Lindhe & Nyman 1985

CHX

0.2 %

2x/d

2 weeks

A

yes

every 2nd week for 12 weeks, 3 month recall

2

Kaldahl & Kalkwarf 1996

n.r.

    

yes

3 month intervals

1

Isidor & Karring 1986

CHX

0.2 %

2x/d

2 weeks

A

yes

2 year 1, professional prophylaxis 3-monthly year 2, 6-monthly years 3, 4 & 5 – subgingival debridement

2

Ramfjord & Caffesse 1987

n.r.

    

yes

1,2,3,4, then every 3 months

2

Kaldahl et al. 1988

n.r.

    

yes

2,4,7 (subgingival plaque removal)

2

Kalkwarf et al1988

n.r.

    

yes

1,2,4,7, then 3 month recall

2

Kalkwarf et al. 1989

n.r.

    

yes

1,2,4,7, then 3 month recall

2

Serino et al. 2001

CHX

0.2 %

2x/d

2 months

C

yes

3–4x/year, re-examinations after 1, 3, 5, 13 years

1