Table 2 Details of 48 papers identified from literature review and reason for exclusion
From: Patient-centred care in general dental practice - a systematic review of the literature
Authors | Title | Journal | Date | Type of article | Reason for exclusion | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Bauer, J., et al. | Interdisciplinary resources optimize Evidence-Based Dental Practice | J Evid Based Dent Pract | 2005 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
2 | Bedos, C., et al. | Patient-centred approaches: new models for new challenges | J. of the Canadian Dental Assoc | 2011 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
3 | Brennan, M., et al. | Patient satisfaction and oral health-related quality of life outcomes of implant overdentures and fixed complete dentures | Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants | 2010 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
4 | Chapple, H., et al. | Exploring dental patients’ preferred roles in treatment decision-making - a novel approach | British Dental Journal | 2003 | QR | Focuses on SDM rather than PCC |
5 | Cobb, D. S. | Patient-centered care in an academic health center: faculty perspective | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
6 | Cohen, L. A., et al. | Comparison of patient centeredness of visits to emergency departments, physicians, and dentists for dental problems and injuries | J Am Coll Dent | 2010 | QUAN | Assessment of level of PCC following dental injury using NHQR questionnaire rather than defining dimensions of PCC |
7 | Dierens, M., et al. | Patient-centered outcome of immediately loaded implants in the rehabilitation of fully edentulous jaws | Clinical Oral Implants Research | 2009 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
8 | Eriksen, H. M., et al. | A patient-centred approach to teaching and learning in dental student clinical practice | Eur J Dent Educ | 2008 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
9 | Fernandes, L., et al. | Patient-centered evaluation of orthodontic care: a longitudinal cohort study of children’s and parents’ attitudes | Am J. of Ortho & Dentofacial Orthopedics | 1999 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
10 | Formicola, A. J., et al. | Evolution of dental school clinics as patient care delivery centers | J Dent Educ | 2006 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
11 | Formicola, A. J., et al. | Evolution of dental school clinics as patient care delivery centers | J Dent Educ | 2008 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
12 | Freeman, R. | Communicating with children and parents: recommendations for a child-parent-centred approach for paediatric dentistry | Eur Arch Paediatr Dent | 2008 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
13 | Gerbert, B., et al. | The provider-patient relationship in academic health centers: the movement toward patient-centered care | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
14 | Gold, S. A. | Managing the patient-centered practice | J Calif Dent Assoc | 2000 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
15 | Hegarty, A. M., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures in oral medicine: are they valid and reliable? | Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2002 | QUAN | Study to compare patient-centred outcome measures and not PCC |
16 | Heymann, H. O. | The “patient-centered” practice | J Esthet Restor Dent | 2008 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
17 | Hietasalo, P., et al. | Cost-effectiveness of an experimental caries-control regimen in a 3.4-yr randomized clinical trial among 11-12-yr-old Finnish schoolchildren | European Journal Of Oral Sciences | 2009 | QUAN | “Patient-centred” used solely as a descriptive term and no reference to PCC. |
18 | Jones, C., et al. | Darzi and Dentistry:The Emerging Quality Agenda for GDPs in England | Dental Update | 2009 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
19 | Hislop, J. M. | Chapter 7: PATIENT-CENTERED COMMUNICATION | Dental Communication Unlimited | 1999 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
20 | Kalkwarf, K. L. | Patient-centered care in an academic health center: an administrator’s perspective | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
21 | Kalkwarf, K. L. | Patient-centered care and today’s dental practice | J Am Coll Dent | 1997 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
22 | Kulich, K. R., et al. | A qualitative analysis of patient-centered dentistry in consultations with dental phobic patients | Journal Of Health Communication | 2003 | QR | INCLUDED |
23 | Levine, R. A. | A patient-centered periodontal program for the 1990s, Part II | Compendium | 1990 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
24 | Levine, R. A. | A patient-centered periodontal program for the 1990s, Part I | Compendium | 1990 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
25 | Loignon, C., et al. | Providing humanistic care: dentists’ experiences in deprived areas | Journal of Dental Research | 2010 | QR | INCLUDED |
26 | Logan, H. L. | What does patient-centered care mean in an academic health center? A conclusion | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
27 | Logan, H. L. | What does patient-centered care mean in an academic health center? An introduction | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
28 | Madhan, B., et al. | Attitudes of postgraduate orthodontic students in India towards patient-centered care | J Dent Educ | 2011 | QUAN | Assessment of level of PCC of ortho students using PPOS questionnaire rather than defining dimensions of PCC |
29 | Mahajan, A., et al. | A Patient-Centered Clinical Evaluation of Acellular Dermal Matrix Graft in the Treatment of Gingival Recession Defects | Journal of Periodontology | 2007 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
30 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures in oral surgery: validity and sensitivity | Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2003 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
31 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred outcome measures for oral mucosal disease are sensitive to treatment | Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg | 2003 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
32 | McGrath, C., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 2. Quality of life | Dent Update | 2007 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
33 | McNair, A., et al. | A qualitative study to develop a tool to examine patients’ perceptions of NHS orthodontic treatment | Journal of Orthodontics | 2006 | QR | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes and patient satisfaction rather than PCC |
34 | Miles, L. L. | The patient-centered practice | J Calif Dent Assoc | 2000 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
35 | Newsome, P., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 1. An overview | Dent Update | 2006 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
36 | Newsome, P., et al. | Patient-centred measures in dental practice: 3. Patient satisfaction | Dent Update | 2007 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
37 | Ni Riordain, R., et al. | A patient-centered approach to developing a quality-of-life questionnaire for chronic oral mucosal diseases | Oral Surg, Oral Med, Oral Path, Oral Rad & Endo | 2011 | QR | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
38 | Nimmo, A., et al. | Patient-centered competency-based education in fixed prosthodontics | J Prosthodont | 1996 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
39 | Pastagia, J., et al. | The effect of patient-centered plaque control and periodontal maintenance therapy on adverse outcomes of periodontitis | The Journal Of Evidence-Based Dental Practice | 2006 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
40 | Phillips, C. | Patient-centered outcomes in surgical and orthodontic treatment | Semin Orthod | 1999 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
41 | Roskell, C., et al. | Developing patient-centred care in health professionals: reflections on introducing service-learning into the curriculum | Int J of Therapy & Rehab | 2012 | QR | Pilot study to promote PCC rather than explore dimensions |
42 | Sachdeva, R. C. | SureSmile technology in a patient--centered orthodontic practice | Journal Of Clinical Orthodontics: JCO | 2001 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
43 | Scambler, S., et al. | Professional attitudes towards disability in special care dentistry | Journal of Disability & Oral Health | 2011 | QR | INCLUDED |
44 | Shenkin, J. D. | Patient-Centered Caries Prevention in Children may be More Cost-Effective in the Long Term than Traditional Dental Care | J Evid Based Dent Pract | 2011 | R | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
45 | Stutts, L. A., et al. | Patient-Centered Outcome Criteria for Successful Treatment of Facial Pain and Fibromyalgia | Journal of Orofacial Pain | 2009 | QUAN | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
46 | Travess, H. C., et al. | The development of a patient-centered measure of the process and outcome of combined orthodontic and orthognathic treatment | J Orthod | 2004 | QR | Concerned with patient-centred outcomes rather than PCC |
47 | Tresolini, C. P. | Health care relationships: instruments for effective patient-focused care in the academic health center | J Dent Educ | 1996 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |
48 | Weinstein, P. | Provider versus patient-centered approaches to health promotion with parents of young children: what works/does not work and why | Pediatr Dent | 2006 | O | NOT PRIMARY RESEARCH |